Welcome to the new RacePA!
I'd just get a B&M. They are only like $75 and will work fine for you. The setrabs are just too expensive IMO.
Good point AJ, definitely won't get a used cooler.Will a B&M have a negative impact on my oil pressure? Its already a little lower than I'd like (40-50psi) if the stock gauge is correct. I was thinking a more expensive oil cooler might be worth it b/c it would have less pressure drop... but I may be way off, and definately trust you guys' experience